Best Electric Griddle Reviews Winners

Best Electric Griddle Reviews 2019

If there’s one underrated electric kitchen device around, it’s the griddle (we absolutely love the Oster CKSTGR3007-ECO). They simply can’t be beat for some of the amazing foods you can prepare on them, and if you’re the right type of cook then chances are you’ll fall in love with a good one.

If you’re here, then you probably know why you need one but you’ve been looking for answers on which is the best. Never fear, we’ve crawled through the depths to bring you the best and help you make a lasting selection.

Oster CKSTGR3007-ECO
Best overall: Oster CKSTGR3007-ECO

It’s expensive, but it’s one of the best. If cost isn’t an option, then this Oster electric griddle is right up your alley.

View On Amazon

Top 5 Electric Griddles

Name Cooking Surface Size Surface Material
Oster CKSTGR3007-ECO 18”x10” Ceramic Check Price
MaxiMatic EGL-3450GD 13”x9.5” Nonstick steel Check Price
BLACK+DECKER GD2011B 20”x11” Nonstick steel Check Price
Presto 07072 Slimline Griddle 22”x13” Nonstick steel Check Price
Presto 07046 Tilt 'n Drain 18.5”x15” Nonstick steel Check Price

1. Best Overall

Oster CKSTGR3007-ECO

Oster CKSTGR3007-ECO

Product Rating 5 /5
Reviewed by:

If you’re looking for the top of the line, this might be the griddle you’ve been looking for. In addition to being both a grill and a griddle in one device, it has a ceramic cooking surface.

It’s not the biggest of our picks, coming in at a middling 10”x18” surface but it’s still good for making breakfast or other meals for three to four people at the same time.

The main advantage of this one is definitely the ceramic surface however. Any kind of utensil can be used on it, it spreads the heat more evenly than any electric griddle we’ve ever seen, and it’ll last longer than any Teflon coated steel has a chance to. It also keeps debris off better than it has any right too. Add in that its dishwasher safe and you have a clear winner of this contest.

Of course, it costs a good bit more than most other electric griddles, but it is the top of the line and the included grill just makes it that much more appealing. The only real drawback is that the temperature control simply isn’t up to par with the rest of the device’s magnificent qualities but it’s still workable as long as you’re careful.

Pros and Cons
  • Ceramic cooking surface
  • Included grill
  • Heats super evenly
  • Easy to clean
  • Surface is truly nonstick
  • Expensive
  • Temperature control not up to par

2. Best Small Size Griddle

MaxiMatic EGL-3450GD

MaxiMatic EGL-3450GD

Product Rating 4.5 /5
Reviewed by:

The MaxiMatic EGL-3450GD is pretty much the perfect electric griddle for a small household. While some might see its 13 inch by 9 ½ inch surface as a mark against it, we choose to see it as easily stored.

The handles don’t transfer heat and the dishwasher safe drip tray makes it fantastically easy to clean at the end of your meal.

The thermostat is easy to operate as well, just turn the dial to the desired temperature and let it heat up. It’ll heat up quickly and efficiently to let you prepare your favorite foods.

The small size lets you cook with it virtually anywhere, if you’re feeling particularly lazy you can probably place it on a towel on the coffee table and cook while you’re watching TV.

Unfortunately, it does seem to have some temperature inconsistencies across the cooking surface, but if you’re quick you should be able to catch it before it does any damage to your food.

For a single person or a pair who doesn’t want to fuss with a large griddle, the MaxiMatic EGL-3450GD is perfect.

Pros and Cons
  • Quick to reach temperature
  • Easy to use
  • Small size
  • Dishwasher safe drip tray
  • Cheap
  • Uneven heating
  • Short cord

3. Best Budget Option



Product Rating 4 /5
Reviewed by:

For a simple, no frills attached griddle this BLACK+DECKER makes a great addition to most kitchens. It comes with a 20”x11” cooking surface that’s suitable for a large group of people and its non-stick cooking surface is well made.

The thermostatic control does a great job of holding the temperature and providing an evenly heated cooking surface which will have you able to bounce around from food item to food item without worrying about hotspots.

It’s even dishwasher safe to make cleaning up when you’re done eating even easier than it would be normally. All of this adds up to a great, budget griddle. There are a couple of issues with it, however, the first is the short cord which is a problem with most electric griddles but the second is a little bit more serious. The grease trap is simply too small for many people, bacon lovers may find themselves having to empty it a bit too often for their liking.

If you want a budget priced, large grill primarily for healthy cooking options instead of frying up pounds of bacon, this is a great option.

Pros and Cons
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Large cooking surface
  • Even heating
  • Truly non-stick surface
  • Budget priced
  • Small grease tray
  • Short cord

4. Best Value For The Money

Presto 07072 Slimline

Presto 07072 Slimline Griddle

Product Rating 4 /5
Reviewed by:

Presto makes some of the best electric griddles around and the Slimline is no exception. The first thing most people will notice, aside from the generous 22 inch by 13 inch nonstick cooking surface is how small it is.

This makes it convenient for crowded kitchens where storage space is at a premium and also makes it lightweight enough you won’t mind having to drag it out of hiding.

While a bit of unevenness is always an issue when it comes to electronic cooking equipment, Presto does a great job of mitigating this as much as possible with their products. This one is certainly no exception, and it does a fine job of it. The removable drip tray is also awesome for fast and easy clean up, allowing you to quickly dump any excess grease out.

The best part is that it’s only a few dollars more than some of the lower-end products out there, giving it a fantastic price to value ratio even if it’s not the cheapest out there.

If you’re not looking for gimmicks, but just want a super easy to use, high-quality electric griddle then the Slimline is exactly what you’re looking for.

Pros and Cons
  • Easy to store
  • Even heating
  • Great price to value ratio
  • Removable drip tray
  • Big cooking surface
  • Drip tray is loose
  • Hard to sink clean due to size

5. Another Great Option

Presto 07046 Tilt

Presto 07046 Tilt 'n Drain Big Griddle

Product Rating 4 /5
Reviewed by:

The Tilt’n’Drain is a great griddle that’s sure to make a lot of people happy, with some unique features for those who demand a bit of something extra from their cooking appliances.

The 18.5”x15” cooking surface easily tilts for when you’re cooking meat and you can level it out again when you’re cooking something that hits the heat as a liquid like eggs. This allows you to drain greasy foods as you cook and saves you on some clean-up.

On top of that, it’s one of Presto’s fine line of electric griddles. It heats fairly evenly, has a good temperature control and the raised lip is a nice touch although it could probably be a little bit higher for some uses.

For those who like to mix things up and get the grease out of their meat, the Presto Tilt’n’Drain simply can’t be beat.

Pros and Cons
  • Big cooking area
  • Tilting capability
  • Easy to clean
  • Even heating
  • Backstop
  • Enormous
  • Legs sometimes unlock while cooking

Who is an Electric Griddle Suitable For?

We’d say everyone, but we’re also big fans of breakfast foods. Many people use them simply for that, you can cook a complete breakfast in one go if you use one, but they’re much more versatile than that.

For the most part, electric griddles are widely used to make any kind of food which doesn’t sputter too much and cooks well on a flat surface. Depending on your tastes you can make anything from pancakes, to quesadillas to fried eggs on them without any fuss at all and one with a sizable cooking area is probably the most efficient way to cook a large breakfast available.

Don’t get them confused with an electric skillet, which is another useful kitchen appliance in their own right. A griddle is great for anything where you don’t need to mix foods.

They do take up a considerable amount of space in your cabinets, but they’re easy to clean for the most part and once you get in the habit it might end up being one of your favorite toys when it comes to meal preparation.

Comparisons to Other Electric Kitchen Appliances

There are a few appliances which will definitely compete for your attention when it comes to an electric griddle. They all have different uses, but not all of us have room for everything.

Electric Skillet vs. Electric Griddle

Electric Skillet

Electric skillets are better for certain foods, particularly if you’re having to mix up a lot of ingredients. With some creativity you can also make pasta and other more complex dishes in one with deep enough sides.

However their surface area is often quite limited and you’ll have more trouble with foods that need to be carefully flipped like pancakes when you’re using one.

Electric Skillet vs. Electric Grill

Electric Grill

Both of these heat quite evenly, and grills and electric skillets are almost the same device in that they’re a smooth, even-heating surface which allows you to make the most of your surface area. For burgers and the like electric grills also add the “grill marks” which some people find immensely appealing.

Grills are much harder to cook foods like eggs on, however, since the uneven surface makes things hard to flip and foods which start the process in a liquid state are going to run. Some electric griddles have interchangeable tops anyways, allowing for the best of all possible worlds in this comparison.

What to Look For in an Electric Griddle

Of course, like anything, there’s a great deal that goes into separating the bad ones from the good ones when it comes down to these handy cooking appliances.


The size of the griddle might not be everything, but for a lot of people it’s the primary consideration. Appropriate sizing for the meals you’re planning on making is a huge factor in making sure you actually use it instead of letting it collect dust in a cabinet.

For those cooking for one or two you can save a lot of money and storage space by utilizing a smaller cooking surface with your griddle. On the other hand, large ones exist which will let you prepare multiple meals at the same time for those who are planning on feeding a big family.

Surface Material

Traditionally griddle cooking surfaces are made of steel or cast iron. Many of them still are and the material definitely holds its own as a superior, low cost material but recently others have come to market with some intriguing qualities.

The most important of the alternate materials is undoubtedly ceramics. Ceramic surfaces can take a good amount of time to heat up, but they’re also inherently non-stick which means you don’t have to worry about getting sloppy with butter or oil in order to cook your food.

Chromed surfaces also exist, they perform similarly to steel but are a bit easier to clean and add a lot to your total cost. The main reason for them is in kitchens which utilize shiny metal as the basis for their appliances where they’ll blend right in and for most people it’s an aesthetic feature.

Grease Well

You want to make sure that any griddle that you care to buy has a good grease well. Catching the grease easily and making it convenient to dispose of it can make all the difference.

This is pretty vital, cheaper ones might develop flaws quickly which will lead to longer clean up times, or in worst case scenarios, a complete and utter mess on your kitchen tabletop.

Extra Features

Thanks to its similarity to many other devices, you can actually get a lot of different uses out of your new electric griddle if you pick one carefully. The most common addition is an interchangeable grill/griddle combination.

There are also tilting versions which make clean up a snap by quickly and efficiently letting you get the grease off with the help of gravity.


Electric griddles are one of the coolest “non-essential” additions you can make to your kitchen, especially if they fit into your daily diet. If you’re persistent enough in making sure that you get the right one for your needs, then you’ll have a nearly daily companion which can make all of the difference when you get down to cooking.


Max Perzon

About Max Perzon

Max is a 28 year old blogger from Sweden that loves to review home related products, and now writes for Homethods full-time. Read more about him