The Best Drywall Patch Repair Kits Reviews 2019

If there’s one main issue that the modern homeowner must face, it’s the fact that drywall dents, dings, and breaks quite easily compared to old-fashioned methods of construction.

Thankfully, there’s a host of different patch kits available which will let even an amateur readily take care of the issue, and we’ve brought the best ones straight to you in order to help you get that wall looking great again.

Best overall: The Wall Doctor Drywall Patch Kit

The Wall Doctor presents us with a unique solution to the problem and makes for a short and easy solution to most holes and dents.

Click For Pricing

What is a Drywall Repair Patch Kit?

In most cases, you’ll find that a kit allows you to get all of the tools and materials necessary in order to get the hole or dent that you need to repair patched up. Essentially, a kit is the tools and materials you’ll need to complete a small repair job.

These are generally the same types of things you’ll find when you’re looking to make the repairs without one, just gathered in one convenient kit to allow you to get the job done quickly.

For the most part, a good repair kit should include the following:

  • Some type of compound
  • A putty knife
  • Sandpaper or something else to smooth the compound
  • Some kind of backing

As long as you have all of that, you’ll be able to take care of most holes in a snap.

Essentially, a drywall patch kit gets all the tools and materials together for you.

Top 5 Best Drywall Patch Repair Kits

Name Patch Type Extra Tools Needed Price
Dap 12345 drydex spackle Self-adhesive aluminum Nothing additional required Check Price
Homax Group 5506 Heavy Duty Self Adhesive Wall Repair Patch Self-adhesive galvanized steel Requires your own spackle and putty knife Check Price
Wall Doctor Drywall Patch Kit Plastic backing None needed Check Price
Marshalltown The Premier Line DP8 8-Inch by 8-Inch drywall repair patch Self-adhesive aluminum Everything, only a patch is included Check Price
3M Patch Plus Primer Kit with 8-Fluid Ounce Self-Adhesive Patch Self-adhesive fiberglass Nothing additional required Check Price

1. Best Overall Patch Repair Kit

The Wall Doctor Drywall Patch Kit

Product Rating 5 /5
Reviewed by:

The Wall Doctor presents us with a unique solution to the problem and makes for a short and easy solution to most holes and dents.

Instead of using “normal” methods, this kit is a bit unique. You’ll find that it comes with a backing and a frame, as well as the compound itself. There’s no putty knife in the kit, and the manufacturer’s claim that one isn’t necessary.

The frame is self-adhesive, and you simply apply it over the cog-shaped backing with your hands. Afterwards, you’ll just need to wait a day or two sand things down in order to get it flush with the wall and have it ready for painting.

The one thing you’ll need to make sure of is to not apply too much pressure to the backing while sanding, the plastic can flex and cause cracking.

For the most part, due to the unique nature of the compound, the Wall Doctor is best for painted walls where the lack of texturing won’t be quite as noticeable.

While it’s novel, it’s not a perfect solution but the Wall Doctor is a newbie-friendly option for those who aren’t already DIY inclined.

Pros and Cons
  • Simple to use
  • No tools necessary
  • Dries for sanding and painting within 24 hours
  • Not a super stable solution
  • Cracking can occur with improper sanding

2. Best For Larger Holes

The 3M Patch Plus Primer Kit with 8-Fluid Ounce Self-Adhesive Patch, Putty knife, and Sanding Pad

Product Rating 4.5 /5
Reviewed by:

This patch kit from 3M is more basic than the Wall Doctor, which also makes it more versatile. It’s a pretty standard affair, and comes with a fiberglass mesh patch and a plastic putty knife.

Where this kit really shines is the compound that it comes with. The compound is both the patch and primer, keeping you from having to lay down another layer when you want to paint the patch to match the surrounding wall.

The patch is 4” across, making it suitable for holes 3” or less across, this lends it to be a rather versatile affair as far as patch kits go.

In addition, it comes with a sanding patch to let you smooth out the wall after you’ve gotten things installed.

The two-in-one primer/patch and the inclusion of all the necessary tools makes this patch kit ideally suited for larger holes being repaired by a novice.

Pros and Cons
  • Two-in-one patch and primer
  • All tools included
  • Large fiberglass patch
  • Fiberglass backing can be hard to work with and maintain a crack free patch

3. Also Great Kit

The Homax Group 5506 Heavy-Duty Self-Adhesive Wall Repair Patch

Product Rating 4 /5
Reviewed by:

This offering from Homax is recommended as a permanent solution to holes in the drywall. 

The extra strength offered by this patch kit mainly comes from the fact that it’s made of galvanized steel. The patch is also self-adhesive saving you from having to lay down a base coat of compound before you get started.

The patch itself is 6”x6” making it suitable for even the biggest holes that you’d want to apply a patch too.

All that you’ll have to do is prep the surface with the included sander, lay down the patch, and spackle it over. Unfortunately, you’ll have to get the compound on your own since the kit only includes the patch itself.

While it’s touted as permanent, you’ll still want to make sure that you keep track of where it is, since you won’t be able to stick anchors in it or anything.

Pros and Cons
  • Heavy duty
  • Self-adhesive patch
  • Galvanized steel can probably take another hit or two
  • Doesn’t come with compound

What Types are Available?

For the most part, kits will be the same across the board. The individual differences can add up in the end though, making some kits far superior to others.

Compound types will differ a little bit between kits, mostly depending on the backing. You’ll be using it to cover up whatever backing is there and in pretty much any case it’ll be the correct formula.

For such a simple-seeming thing, there’s a huge variation in the different types of compounds which can be used on walls. For the most part, though, all you need to do is follow the instructions that will come with the kit and you’ll be good.

The backing type will vary quite a bit, while some kits will give you a piece of fiberglass mesh, others will have you apply a galvanized steel mesh or even plastic. For the most part, non-ferrous metals or fiberglass are preferred, as there’s very little chance of them corroding or falling apart over time.

We’ll go more in depth into the differences in the types of patch you can acquire with your kit shortly.

One thing that is pretty much always minimal in kits will be the putty knife. While a plastic knife will work for the most part, they’re often not good for much after you’re done with the kit, particularly if you don’t clean them off. If you’ve got a good putty knife around already, use that instead.

The sanding device included is usually pretty simple, a single sheet of sandpaper or a sanding sponge. Either way, you can usually take or leave these as most of us have something around that will get the job done at the end of the day.

There are also some rather novel kits on the market which use slightly different methods, but for the most part the type you pick will be dictated by the size of the hole and what’s available to you, rather than any inherent superiority of the kit in question.

What are the Advantages of a Drywall Repair Kit?

Convenience is probably the most common reason for someone to opt to use a kit. If you’re not used to working with drywall, then you’re going to be able to get all of the tools you need in one shot and there’s instructions included.

Some of the kits offer longer lasting backings that can cover some surprisingly large holes, metal screens are particularly good in this respect.

If you’ve never worked with drywall before, kits are a fantastic option.

If you have worked with drywall frequently, however, you probably have what you need lying around in the garage and the main advantage offered to you by using one is just that you don’t have to dig out a big bucket of compound or search for the tools in the garage.

When Should I Use a Kit?

Kits aren’t appropriate for every hole in the wall. Large holes and dents will have to be taken care of by a full repair rather than a patch.

If you’ve managed to damage a wall in an area over about 4” by 4” you’re better off repairing the wall rather than using a smaller kit. It’ll take more effort, but the repair will be lasting and it will restore structural integrity to the wall itself.

If the hole is smaller than that, or if you’re just covering dents, then you’re probably looking at a good candidate for a patch kit. Overall, you’ll find that they’re best for minor repairs, at least in size.

The main difference between a patch and an actual repair is that the latter will restore the structural integrity of the wall and allow you to use it for anchors and other uses which require the sheetrock be fully present, while a patch is primarily cosmetic.

Keep track of any patches you’ve made in your home. You’re going to be sorely disappointed and have a mess on your hands if you later decide to drive an anchor somewhere you made a patch previously.

After care of patches is usually remarkably easy, a bit of touch up with paint and texturing and you’ll find that the wall looks good as new for the most part.

Features to Compare

The main thing you’ll need to do is make sure that the patch kit you’re going to purchase covers a large enough area to keep everything covered. In the case of holes you’re going to be simply out of luck, and in the case of dents it’s not going to make much of an improvement.

After this, compare the backing type.

Metal backings are sturdier than the other types, but make sure that you use them only in dry environments. They’re not suitable for bathrooms, for instance, since the ambient moisture can cause them to corrode and eventually fail.

Fiberglass mesh on the other hand is surprisingly resilient to moisture and can keep mold out of the walls. Fiberglass itself is actually responsible for the moisture and mold resistant qualities in green board, the type of sheetrock which is recommended for areas with large amounts of moisture in the air.

Fiberglass has some disadvantages though, the flexible nature of the material means it can do some weird stuff if the compound isn’t applied properly. Hairline fractures are the most common, but if you’re using fiberglass everything will be fine if you’re careful.

Plastic patches are fairly uncommon, and probably the least popular of the three basic materials you’re likely to run across. The main problem is that for a plastic patch to be thin enough to not stick out from the wall they’re quite likely to flex while any kind of later finishing is being done.

This means that if you choose to use a plastic patch, it’s imperative that you be extremely careful during the finishing process to avoid cracking once the mud is dry. Extra surface smoothing is a good idea, as you’ll require less sanding after the installation.


Finally, if you’re looking for a permanent solution to the problem: make sure the compound can be textured, sanded, and painted before you purchase the kit. You’ll need all of that to make sure that the wall looks seamless at the end of the job.


Max Perzon

About Max Perzon

Max is a 28 year old blogger from Sweden that loves to review home related products, and now writes for Homethods full-time. Read more about him