Best Baby Crib Mattress Review

The Best Baby Crib Mattress in 2019 – Honest Review

We reviewed some of the best baby crib mattresses on the market. If you’re looking for an instant solution that is suitable for most babies, take a look at our number one pick, Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed. With high-end design, this mattress is 100% breathable, non-toxic, and ideal for babies of all sizes. If you’re looking for a mattress of a different type or features, make sure to check the runner-ups and give our buying guide a peek!

Best overall: Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed

With dimensions of 52 x 28 x 5.5 inches and weight of 11 pounds, this baby mattress is made of 10% food-grade polymer and 90% free air. It is 100% breathable, washable, hypoallergenic, non-toxic, and proven to reduce the risks of suffocation.

Click For Pricing

Top 5 Baby Crib Mattresses

Name Material Weight (Pounds) Price
Newton Baby Crib Mattress 90% Free Air, 10% Food-grade Polymer 11 Check Price
Milliard Pack and Play Tri-Fold Polyester, Foam 5.2 Check Price
Colgate Eco Classica III Eco Foam, Cotton 9.44 Check Price
Milliard Waterproof Crib Mattress Foam 9.8 Check Price
Dream On Me Playard Mattress Vinyl 10%, Foam 90% 3.5 Check Price

1. Best Overall Baby Crib Mattress


Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed

Product Rating 5 /5
Reviewed by:

Whether your home is located in a warm area or you just want to make sure that your little one stays comfortable at all times, this baby mattress lets air flow freely to reduce overheating. Designed for infants and toddlers, it features breathable materials and improves baby’s sleep quality by eliminating sweaty back.

Made of 10% food-grade polymer and 90% free air, this mattress has temperature regulating feature to keep your little one as comfortable as possible while sleeping. It also reduces the risk of suffocation as it allows babies to breathe through the mattress. This feature makes it ideal for infants who tend to roll on their stomachs overnight.

With product dimensions of 52 x 28 x 5.5 inches, this organic mattress fits in standard sized cribs. Being Greenguard Gold Certified, it doesn’t contain springs, latex, foam, glue, allergens, and it has lowest VOCs. This reduces your worry about allergic reactions or off-gassing.

Weighing only 11 pounds, it is completely washable to make cleaning an easy job for parents. The 3D spacer cover is also easily removable and can be washed in a machine with cold water for a fresher and cleaner crib.

Pros and Cons
  • Breathable design to reduce overheating and suffocation
  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Made of 10% food-grade polymer and 90% free air
  • Mattress and 3D fabric are washable
  • It easily fits in standard sized cribs
  • Pricier than other brands
  • Some parents have reported that the texture is a bit rough

2. Best Portable Baby Crib Mattress


Milliard Pack and Play Tri-Fold Mattress

Product Rating 4.5 /5
Reviewed by:

Made of high-density, top-quality foam, this mattress gives the right balance between soft comfort and firm support to help your baby get optimal hours of sleep. With dimensions of 38 x 26 x 1.5 inches, it has rounded corners and gives plenty of space for your little one to sleep or play during the day. Its main feature is that it is foldable into three parts, making it easy to store or pack.

The Pack’N’Play Mattress by Milliard is also encased in a fireproof fiberglass lining for additional safety of your little one.

It also comes with a cover that is both washable and waterproof, so there is no need to fret about maintaining the cleanliness of the mattress.  The fabric cover is soft outside and has a special inverted laminating to prevent liquids from soaking the mattress.

Ideal for traveling and moving around, this baby mattress weighs only 5.2 pounds and has a trifold design to let you easily fold it up into the carry bag that is included in the package.

Pros and Cons
  • Easy to store and highly portable
  • Rounded corners
  • Both durable and soft
  • It comes with a waterproof and washable cover
  • Fireproof, fiberglass lining for additional safety
  • Some reviewers mentioned that it is not thick enough
  • Middle part may sink

3. Best Eco Foam Baby Crib Mattress


Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco Foam Crib Mattress

Product Rating 4 /5
Reviewed by:

For those who are looking for a mattress that can grow with your child, this might be the right item for your baby’s crib. The Eco Classica III lets you flip the bed from the firm side to the soft side during the transition from infant to toddler stage. This enables you to save money by avoiding the need to purchase another mattress.

With a width of 6 inches, its dual firmness makes it an ideal baby mattress for the development and growth of your child. This also means that there are no loose covers that may prevent babies from sleeping comfortably.

To offer this support, the mattress is constructed with Eco-foam-based plant oils instead of petroleum-based oils for additional safety. It is also Greenguard Children and Schools Certified, meaning it meets all necessary standards. It is free of over 10,000 volatile compounds that are dangerous for kids’ health.

With dimensions of 51.7 x 27.5 x 6 inches and weight of 9.44 pounds, this mattress comes with a certified organic cotton cover that has waterproof backings to protect the mattress from accidental wetness.

Pros and Cons
  • Greenguard Children and Schools Certified
  • Dual firmness feature provides support for infants and comfort to toddlers
  • It comes with a certified organic cotton cover with waterproof backing
  • Phthalate-free and hypoallergenic
  • Eco foam is constructed with plant oils
  • No edge support
  • The seam may start protruding

4. Best Baby Crib Mattress for Waterproof Nights


Milliard Waterproof Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Product Rating 4 /5
Reviewed by:

For those who are looking for a baby mattress that won’t flatten over time while giving comfort, this item might be the one that you’ve been searching for. It uses a unique blend of foam to achieve the right combination of safety and comfort for both newborns and toddlers. Many parents have reported that their babies sleep longer when using this product.

This mattress is also firm enough to prevent SIDS. It has a density of 28D to keep your baby comfortable without sinking in. Constructed of 5-inch thick, luxurious, high-quality foam, it reduces turning and tossing to help your little one sleep better. It also gently contours to the curves of your baby’s body to prevent aches, stress, and muscle pain.

With a weight of 9.8 pounds and dimensions of 52 x 27.5 x 5 inches, this mattress fits in standard sized cribs. It also implements a fiberglass lining and meets all fire safety regulations.

The entire mattress is covered with a non-porous, hypoallergenic, waterproof cover which keeps unwanted substances from infiltrating your baby’s comfort zone.

The cover protects the mattress against mold, bacteria, allergens and dust mites, making it ideal for babies suffering from asthma or allergies.

Pros and Cons
  • Foam doesn’t flatten over time and prevents SIDS
  • Meets fire safety regulations
  • It is encased in a hypoallergenic and waterproof cover
  • Ideal for asthma and allergy sufferers
  • Contours to the curves of baby’s body
  • Has unpleasant odor during the first three days
  • The cover is a bit hard

5. Best Affordable Baby Crib Mattress


Dream On Me Playard Mattress

Product Rating 3.5 /5
Reviewed by:

Made of 90% foam and 10% vinyl, this mattress meets the ASTM Standards and the 16 CFR 1632/1633 Federal Flammability Standards to ensure both quality and safety. It is lead- and phthalates-free, reducing parents’ worries about hazardous substances that may be present in other mattresses on the market.

This mattress comes with a cover to make cleaning a simple task. It has air-flow systems, hypoallergenic components, insulation, and water-proofing components that let you wipe your little one’s mattress clean with water and mild soap.

If you are searching for an all-around playpen mattress, this product by Dream On Me might impress you. The cover is also stain-resistant and waterproof to protect against liquids, preventing odors, mildew, and mold from seeping into the mattress.

This bed also comes with perimeter border-wires to ensure that it won’t sag as the airflow pickets keep the entire bed fresh. With a size of 37.5 x 25.5 x 3 inches, it fits the Graco Square Pack N’ Play, and it accommodates babies from 3 to 45 pounds.

Pros and Cons
  • Waterproof and antibacterial lock-stitched binding
  • Prevents mildew, odor, and mold
  • Meet the 16 CFR 1632/1633 Federal Flammability Standards and ASTM Standards
  • Border-wires prevent sagging
  • Laminated waterproof cover
  • Some reviewers mentioned that it is stiffer than what they expected
  • Very thin

Crib Mattress Matters!

Are you looking for a mattress on which your baby will be able to sleep like an angel? Having the right cushioning for baby’s crib not only promotes sound sleep but also contributes to the healthy development of the child and prevention of sudden infant death syndrome. Selecting the right mattress from a wide range of offers, however, is one of the toughest decisions that every parent has to face eventually. With so many different types of mattresses and features that they offer, you want to make sure you get one that will satisfy all of your baby’s needs. To help you choose the best crib mattress, we have prepared an extensive guide including top products on the market as well as information on what to consider before the purchase.

There’s more to this type of beds than it meets the eye. Crib mattresses are designed to provide ultimate comfort and safety for newborn babies, infants, and toddlers. With that said, keep in mind that a regular mattress can’t and should not be used to replace a mattress designed for babies.

If you have other types of cushioning, such as large pillows, for example, you shouldn’t use them in the crib of your baby. Such products are not designed with babies’ safety in mind which is why they may encourage sudden infant death syndrome.

When it comes to your baby, it is better not to improvise. Invest in a reliable crib mattress that will ease your worries and make your baby safer.

Important Features to Consider When Buying a Mattress

Top 5 Baby Crib Mattresses

One of the most important factors in choosing a new crib mattress is its type. This feature will significantly impact the product’s price, functionality, and the level of comfort it offers.

Foam Mattress

This type of mattress is the most popular choice amongst parents and is considered to have the best ratio between quality, price, and convenience. Foam crib mattresses are normally composed of polyurethane and weigh around 3 – 12 pounds.


  • The most affordable option of all mattress types.
  • Lightweight and portable, therefore easy to move around.
  • Available in a wide variety of sizes and designs.
  • Usually come with a waterproof cover that is easy to clean.


  • Not as durable as its alternatives.
  • Not recommended for long-term use.

Organic Mattress

These are made of 100% organic material which is why they are the most environmentally- and baby-friendly. Due to high-quality materials invested in the making, organic mattresses are also the most expensive amongst the three main types.


  • Organic and free of potential allergens and dangerous chemicals that might be present in certain foam mattresses.
  • Long-lasting and durable.
  • Very breathable and friendly to the baby’s skin.


  • Not very common in today’s market.

Innerspring Mattress

They are a heavy and bulky version of mattress that can weigh anywhere up to 30 pounds. Innerspring mattresses consist of coils covered with foam, lining, and fabric.


  • Durable and long-lasting, therefore most appropriate for toddlers.


  • More expensive than foam mattresses.
  • Very heavy and hard to move around and clean thoroughly.

Which type is the right one for me?

If the budget allows it, opt for an organic baby crib mattress to reduce the chances of your baby experiencing health or sleeping issues.

Foam mattresses are also an excellent alternative that you might want to give a try. They are affordable, lightweight, and reliable, making them an ideal solution for most families.

Due to issues with heavy weight and limited portability, we don’t encourage parents to get an innerspring mattress. You might, however, be interested in this type if you don’t intend to move the mattress around and aim to use it for many years.


Picking the right mattress size is crucial to ensure that it will fit tightly in the crib. As there should be no space left between the crib frame and the side of the mattress, it is important that you measure your crib carefully before buying a mattress.

While the federal laws have pretty much standardized the minimum and maximum dimensions of cribs and mattresses, there are still slight variations between the products that you should be aware of.


The materials used in the mattress greatly determine the product’s quality and usability.

  • Foam: If you have decided to opt for a foam mattress, pick one with a high-density polyurethane core. The higher the density of foam mattresses, the more pressure they can withstand without deforming.
  • Organic materials: Organic mattresses can be made of a wide variety of all-natural materials such as wool, cotton, coconut fibers, natural latex, plant-based foam, and food-grade polymers.
  • Coils: The more coils the mattress has, the firmer it typically is. If you decide to get an innerspring mattress, make sure to get one with plenty of coils.

Additionally, pay attention to the type and quality of padding and cover that the mattress comes with.


Mattresses designed for children and adults are usually too soft for babies. When it comes to their safety, the firmer the mattress is, the better.

If the mattress looks or feels too stiff to you don’t worry, your baby will easily adjust to its firmness. Upon pressing on the center of a baby mattress, the cushion should immediately snap back in its original form and should not adapt to the pressure of the body.


In general, innerspring and organic mattresses are heavier than their foam alternatives and can weigh up to 30 pounds. While foam mattresses usually weigh around 5 – 10 pounds, they may also be much heavier if made of high-density polyurethane.

When picking a new mattress, make sure to carefully consider its weight and ask yourself questions such as:

  • Will I move the mattress around a lot?
  • Do I intend to use it in different spaces?
  • How long do I expect it to be used?

If you’re in need of a short-term solution or something that you can easily move wherever you want, opt for mattresses that are lightweight.


The cover of the mattress is arguably just as important as the mattress itself. The purpose of the cover is not only to protect the mattress from spills and diaper leaks but also from bacteria growth and bad smell.

Before investing in a crib mattress, make sure to check whether a quality cover is included in the purchase or not. If not, you can always buy it separately but know that a quality cover might cost you a small fortune.

What to look for in a mattress cover?

Important Features to Consider When Buying a Mattress

  • Breathability: It is important that the air around the baby flows freely to keep the sleeping surface cool and fresh.
  • Water resistance: Waterproofing helps the mattress retain good shape and prevent it from absorbing moisture.

Different Types of Covers

Most conventional mattresses feature a waterproof cover made of vinyl, nylon, or polyethylene. These covers are highly affordable and relatively durable. They may, however, pose issues when it comes to breathability and the health of your child.

Cloth cover solutions are also taking over the market rapidly. These are typically made of undyed and unbleached cotton. Bamboo yarn is also gaining popularity due to its antimicrobial properties and the status of being a highly renewable source. Despite their benefits, cloth covers may have issues with water resistance and might encourage bacteria growth if you don’t use an additional waterproof lining.

If you want to fix all problems at once, opt for a cover that is made of natural materials such as cotton on one side and waterproof, antibacterial surface on the other.


Are you looking for a mattress that your baby will be able to use even after transiting from an infant into a toddler? Some mattresses offer a dual firmness feature, meaning that an infant bed can be converted into a toddler mattress simply by turning it around.

Your newborn baby or infant can sleep on the firm side of the mattress. This will ensure proper development and help prevent security risks. Once the baby grows up and starts craving comfort, you can simply turn the mattress around and let the baby sleep on the softer side.

Additionally, you might also be interested in a mattress that can be easily folded and transported. Those are most convenient for parents who like to travel with their babies.


Fortunately, crib mattresses don’t have to be very expensive to be safe and convenient enough for most babies.

Foam mattresses are typically the most affordable ones and can be purchased for as little as $50 - $100.

Innerspring mattresses are also relatively affordable, especially if considering they last longer, and usually cost around $100 - $200.

Organic mattresses are the most expensive amongst the three main types. They are also associated with lower risks and the highest level of convenience and comfort. Organic mattress can cost you anywhere from $250 upwards.


Conventional mattresses normally support spot-cleaning only. Some of them come with a removable cover that can be washed in a machine. If you want a mattress that is fully washable, be ready to spend the extra bucks because those usually cost a lot more than their alternatives.

Important Safety Notes

Here are some final pieces of advice when it comes to crib mattresses and putting babies to sleep that might help your baby stay safe:

  • Avoid used crib mattresses. With time, mattresses get worn out and become a hotspot of bacteria or fungus growth. Additionally, they are prone to losing firmness over time which may result in higher risks for the baby.
  • Avoid air mattresses (and other soft surfaces). While they may be tempting, air mattresses are too soft and therefore not suitable for babies. The soft surface presents a serious suffocation hazard and shouldn’t be taken
  • Eliminate suffocation hazards. Never place a baby in a bed with loose blankets or other bedding objects that might increase risks of suffocation. Avoid pillows, quilts, sheepskins, comforters, and stuffed toys as well. This rule is especially relevant for newborn babies and infants.
  • Adjust the sleeping position. Always place your baby down on their back as they are going to sleep.
  • Adjust the blanket position. When swaddling your baby, make sure that the blanket isn’t rubbing against baby’s cheeks. Prolonged rubbing can cause skin rashes and discomfort.


Buying the right mattress will do wonders for your child, both in the sense of providing comfort as well as security. With the innovations on the rise, mattresses now offer various features and come in several types to make the life of your baby more comfortable and their everyday routines more convenient. All these options, however, come with an overwhelming task of doing your research before buying a mattress to make sure you get the right product.

While the Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed ranked #1 on our list due to its top-notch design and outstanding features such as breathability and water resistance, all of the mattresses introduced in this guide have something to offer that others don’t. Now that you know what exactly to look for based on your child’s needs, it’s time to review your needs and pick the best crib mattress for your baby!


Max Perzon

About Max Perzon

Max is a 28 year old blogger from Sweden that loves to review home related products, and now writes for Homethods full-time. Read more about him